|
Post by Paid Debt Lannister on May 25, 2015 6:30:39 GMT
There were two threads on older episodes, one fearing for Shireen's fate, and the other for Olenna's. I am creating this one just for us to discuss a bit more about that after today's episode.
Shireen seems to be at a very big risk IMO. I am sure at least an attempted burning will happen. She may be saved by Davos or Stannis, but I don't think Mel will give up that easily after this week's conversation.
And Olenna seems very powerless this year, doesn't she? She couldn't do a thing so far, and even the Lancel maneuver was orchestrated by LF. Besides, it only got Cersei arrested, but doesn't free either of her grandchildren. Plus, she threatened LF direct to his face, saying she will talk if she goes down. After this, I think LF may off her himself.
What do you guys think? Will either of them make it to S6?
|
|
|
Post by arthucus on May 25, 2015 6:53:03 GMT
I'd say all of the normally powerful character seem powerless this season. Even Littlefinger and Varys are mostly powerless and will remain so until someone disarms the faith. Cersei has lost her power, and the Crown itself seems powerless. That's in AFfC/ADwD, but the show brought Tyrion and Dany together, took us to Valyria, and had Brienne find both Stark Girls.
Sansa's storyline is hard to watch, but it could have been worse. Poor Jayne.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2015 8:23:37 GMT
I'd say all of the normally powerful character seem powerless this season. Even Littlefinger and Varys are mostly powerless and will remain so until someone disarms the faith. Cersei has lost her power, and the Crown itself seems powerless. That's in AFfC/ADwD, but the show brought Tyrion and Dany together, took us to Valyria, and had Brienne find both Stark Girls. Sansa's storyline is hard to watch, but it could have been worse. Poor Jayne. You're definitely onto a running theme this season... loss of power and the downward spiral of many main characters to the brink of destruction. It's one of the reasons I loved ADWD so much - the apocalyptic feel was real haha! I just couldn't imagine (and still can't) HOW anyone was going to come out of this and win. Arya was also blinded going through her ordeal so even though the show's not there and may not go there - she's in a weakened state as well. Littlefinger is really working himself into a precarious spot on the show more than he was in the book, but I imagine he still holds quite a bit of power in King's Landing. He wasn't famous for his brothel after all. Olenna's threats probably aren't much to him and he could definitely have her killed easily but Margaery knows who killed Joffrey too - maybe she'll spill the beans on him? But regardless, I don't think they'll kill off Olenna anytime soon - she's really the only Tyrell left to carry the story right now. As for Shireen, I voiced my opinion on this in the other thread, but I really do not get a strong feeling of foreboding for Shireen. I think maybe they're hoping it looks that way - and they intend to make it pretty uncertain for her for awhile, but I think in the end she'll be spared. It's good suspense to try and lead the viewers along a little bit like that but having Melisandre come right out and suggest it boldly to Stannis doesn't mean it's going to happen in fact it probably means it's not going to happen. They gave it away too easily.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 25, 2015 8:32:25 GMT
I think it's possible that Stannis sends Mel and Selyse and Shireen away, hoping that Selyse being the girl's mother won't harm her. But she does :/
|
|
|
Post by Paid Debt Lannister on May 25, 2015 8:38:45 GMT
The problem is that Shireen was set up on the fourth season... At that time I thought she might become the heir, but now we know Melisandre has plans for burning her for a while already. I am not saying she is dead for sure, but I don't think this is the end of this matter... There is still some shit to hit the fan on this matter.
As for the Tyrells, on the books as desperate as their situation seems, it always seemed to me that Cersei was the most doomed one. Afterall, Mace is still a powerful lord, Tarly's troops are in the city, Willas and Garlan exist and Olenna is far away in Highgarden. But on the show, their heir and queen are imprisoned (and the HS seems to be eager to off both), Nana Tyrell is in harm zone and is pretty incompetent, Mace may be killed by Meryn or Arya, and we don't know if Randyll exists. They're in a much, much worse situation on the show. Besides, nobody takes Olenna's threats about cutting the food supplies for some reason.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2015 8:46:35 GMT
What makes you think the High Sparrow wants to off both Margaery and Loras? He only said (to Cersei) the punishment would depend on the situation and their crimes and how the trial goes... it's not like a trial for murder as was Tyrion's case. In fact I'm far more inclined to think the punishment will be whippings or public humiliation similar to Cersei's walk of shame. Margaery's only crime is lying in front of the Gods - that is not punishable by death is it? What she was accused of in the books was more severe. Loras, I doubt would die for being gay ... we've never heard or seen anyone being punished for that before anywhere under the faith of the Seven.
I actually don't think anyone's going to get killed by the Faith, not even Cersei. Call me crazy, I know! The people who would have the most to fear (I think) would be those who committed regicide to be honest. The Incest and fake Baratheon kids might be a bigger crime as well - but homosexuality and lying? Not as severe IMO.
Edit: They did however kill that gay guy in Littlefinger's Brothel, right? But that was being caught in the act by the faith militant directly... so I don't know if the stakes are the same for Loras but as a second thought, I suppose he could have a risk.
Olenna has a bigger risk of being killed off by Littlefinger than anyone but probably not until the end of the season or next season. Still betting it doesn't happen.
|
|
|
Post by 7timesdamnedshewolf on May 25, 2015 8:53:04 GMT
I think Mace is the safest of them all, more likely Arya will save him without even realizing it when she offs Meryn.
I think the book Tyrells are in for major fall through some means tbh, they switched sides and come out on top way too many times without a scratch. Between crowning the usurper Renly, starving KL when Renly was alive, then saving the Lannisters from Stannis's justice only to murder Joffrey in a frame job that set off Cersei's dwarf slaughter and other bloodshed, House Tyrell has a lot of scheming to answer for in the game of thrones. I think they need a named casualty after all the losses every other major house has suffered.
And no way the show would prematurely cut Olenna after making so much more use of than the books did. LF's a petty guy but mutual threats and posturing is probably the closest he ever gets to friendship, he never directly moved against Varys until Varys had Ros as a double agent, and even then her death wasn't really a hit for Varys. I can easily imagine his and Olenna's partnership always being contentious.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2015 12:56:19 GMT
I don't know about Olenna, but I bet this will happen concerning Shireen in 5x09:
Pray harder.
|
|
|
Post by kingeomer on May 25, 2015 13:11:07 GMT
For some reason I am not worried about Oleanna and Shireen. Call me crazy. I don't think Shireen gets burned. I think Oleanna gets taken down several pegs and I think Margarey or Loras might die. I think people do not take Olenna's threats seriously because they know she can be bought especially if it will benefit her family.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2015 15:00:03 GMT
I think it's possible that Stannis sends Mel and Selyse and Shireen away, hoping that Selyse being the girl's mother won't harm her. But she does :/ I always perceived Stannis being fully aware that Selyse doesn't have much affection for Shireen. (When they talked in Season 3 and Selyse told him not to visit her for example.) She even showed more love for her preserved fetus, seven hells.
|
|
|
Post by day dreamer on May 25, 2015 15:13:28 GMT
I'm not too worried at this point. I don't think they would've given us that touching scene between Stannis and Shireen if he was going to okay her burning. I think he stands his ground with telling Mel "no" and that shot of Selyse crying is because Mel is leaving.
As for Olenna, I'm not worried about her safety at all. I think she probably succeeds in making some sparrows' lives harder.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on May 25, 2015 18:15:19 GMT
I hate how tired and defeated Stannis looked. Like a man at the end of the road
|
|
|
Post by theonionsleight on May 25, 2015 18:50:59 GMT
I'm completely euchred because of the whole Stannis/Shireen thing, I'm just a nervous wreck atm... Scared as hell and I'm not sure if I want or don't want to see the next three episodes... I just feel one of them, if not even both, are dead meat soon ...
|
|
|
Post by associatemaester on May 25, 2015 19:04:46 GMT
I hate how tired and defeated Stannis looked. Like a man at the end of the road He actually looks better than he does in the books at this point. Asha basically describes his as walking death.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 25, 2015 21:44:33 GMT
I'm not too worried at this point. I don't think they would've given us that touching scene between Stannis and Shireen if he was going to okay her burning. I think he stands his ground with telling Mel "no" and that shot of Selyse crying is because Mel is leaving. As for Olenna, I'm not worried about her safety at all. I think she probably succeeds in making some sparrows' lives harder. Well said and I agree that special scene between Stannis and Shireen was not done to put the fear in us she's going to die, but to reconfirm how much she really means to Stannis so that when it comes down to the wire and he has to chose between sacrificing his daughter to (possibly) save his men through Mel's sorcery, he'll choose his daughter. The only way I would think he would change his mind is if she's about to die anyways from the cold or something and I don't think they get that bad off even with losing men left and right. Selyse crying because Mel just got pissed and decided to go back to the wall makes a lot more sense - especially if Stannis forbids her going with her because he wants to keep Shireen safe. He knows full well how bat shit crazy Selyse is and that she'd bend to Mel's wishes in a second.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2015 16:01:39 GMT
I just have a sense that both Shireen and Olenna are safe, at least for the foreseeable future. Shireen d/t reasons already posted,i.e. scene showing Stannis' love for her, and Olenna because I just think she'll give LF a run for his money. LF wasn't successful in manipulating Roose, who is 'wise' to him, and I just think (hope) he's losing a bit of power. He'd need The Reach, same reasons he needs The North, and he knows Olenna is the real power there. Wishful thinking on my part, but maybe the demolished brothel is symbolic/foreboding of LF's demise, or at least his decline (I suspect he'll be around till the end, when I hope Varys and 'helpers' will take him out. Sansa sure isn't going to trust him any more. Stannis may have (???) made some sort of 'deal' with LF, but he has some respect for the Starks, and if he ever finds out what Roose has allowed to happen to Sansa, I think he'll be pissed. [And I'm banking on Stannis taking WF instead of Roose prevailing]. About Mel, I keep thinking about how, in the books, she looked into her precious flames and saw Jon instead of Stannis. Also thinking about book Mel being around when Jon is stabbed. I really don't want her to be the one who brings him back, don't want her to have any hold over him at all, but/and a little afraid she might somehow find out about Jon/Targaryen royalty. So, getting back to main point about Shireen, I think Mel will leave for the Wall before she has a chance to harm Shireen. As far as the promo of Selyse on the ground - wouldn't it be great (my dream world) - for Stannis to find she is plotting with Mel to sacrifice Shireen and finally take her out of the picture entirely in order to save Shireen.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2015 18:00:53 GMT
I just have a sense that both Shireen and Olenna are safe, at least for the foreseeable future. Shireen d/t reasons already posted,i.e. scene showing Stannis' love for her, and Olenna because I just think she'll give LF a run for his money. LF wasn't successful in manipulating Roose, who is 'wise' to him, and I just think (hope) he's losing a bit of power. He'd need The Reach, same reasons he needs The North, and he knows Olenna is the real power there. Wishful thinking on my part, but maybe the demolished brothel is symbolic/foreboding of LF's demise, or at least his decline (I suspect he'll be around till the end, when I hope Varys and 'helpers' will take him out. Sansa sure isn't going to trust him any more. Stannis may have (???) made some sort of 'deal' with LF, but he has some respect for the Starks, and if he ever finds out what Roose has allowed to happen to Sansa, I think he'll be pissed. [And I'm banking on Stannis taking WF instead of Roose prevailing]. About Mel, I keep thinking about how, in the books, she looked into her precious flames and saw Jon instead of Stannis. Also thinking about book Mel being around when Jon is stabbed. I really don't want her to be the one who brings him back, don't want her to have any hold over him at all, but/and a little afraid she might somehow find out about Jon/Targaryen royalty. So, getting back to main point about Shireen, I think Mel will leave for the Wall before she has a chance to harm Shireen. As far as the promo of Selyse on the ground - wouldn't it be great (my dream world) - for Stannis to find she is plotting with Mel to sacrifice Shireen and finally take her out of the picture entirely in order to save Shireen. Many good points you've made I would re-iterate on: - Olenna and Littlefinger are a great verbal sparring team much the way Varys and Littlefinger were in seasons past. They'd be fools to get rid of her or Littlefinger either one right now and will ride that pony for as long as they can. That doesn't mean either of them are 'safe' (book or show) as obviously we have no idea who makes it to endgame at this point. - This probably sounds odd, but I actually don't want Littlefinger to die until the very end and like you, I think he will in fact be around for a long while yet. I think his chaos ladder is really interesting and to me, he's a far more fascinating villain than the tired psycho-movie-trope type like Joffrey and Ramsay. Now that's not to say the show writers haven't messed him up just a bit from book Littlefinger but I'm still rooting for him as a villain until the end game showdown. - Selyse is a goner in my book, one way or another. They've set her up to be Lysa II, so your idea that maybe Stannis himself gets rid of her is quite interesting and one I'd get behind and support if that's the way the show takes it but I'm sure many Stannis fans would be outraged by suggesting that sort of smear on his reputation! - Shireen will be safe so long as Davos and Stannis are nearby. Stannis just told Mel to piss off so I would not be at all surprised if she takes off for the wall in a huff after deciding whatever she saw in the fires was all BS anyways and now Jon's the real key to "Red Rahloo" (I think that's what Fire and Blood calls him LOL) which of course makes Jon Snow fans furious but hey, there needs to be some sort of catalyst in the ice and fire thing, right?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2015 18:04:12 GMT
PS: My remark about Selyse being "Lysa II" just reminded me of something. What do some of you think of the very vague possibility of Shireen being paired off with Sweet Robin? If Stannis manages to take Winterfell and win the north, it would be a brilliant political match to seal alliance with the Vale. This would of course be next season / book theory material.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2015 18:07:30 GMT
PS: My remark about Selyse being "Lysa II" just reminded me of something. What do some of you think of the very vague possibility of Shireen being paired off with Sweet Robin? If Stannis manages to take Winterfell and win the north, it would be a brilliant political match to seal alliance with the Vale. This would of course be next season / book theory material. No. Shireen doesn't deserve that sickly little maniack.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 26, 2015 18:16:04 GMT
PS: My remark about Selyse being "Lysa II" just reminded me of something. What do some of you think of the very vague possibility of Shireen being paired off with Sweet Robin? If Stannis manages to take Winterfell and win the north, it would be a brilliant political match to seal alliance with the Vale. This would of course be next season / book theory material. No. Shireen doesn't deserve that sickly little maniack. Oh I agree, he's a turd and she deserves better but you have to admit it could be a powerful match and Shireen's probably never going to marry for love. Also, now that he's away from his insane Mother, he might actually tun out half decent if the Vale lords toughen him up a bit. I'm a big believer in anyone being able to change with the right handling. He's also not really that sickly in the show like he is in the books. I think he has minor epilepsy or something in the book and felt like he was probably never going to live to adulthood. Show Robert/Robin is just a wimpy shithead.
|
|