kelly
Fleabottom Peasant
Posts: 16
|
Post by kelly on Jul 5, 2016 20:54:04 GMT
Haha, this isn't going to end anytime soon is it.
|
|
GreenChili
Grumpkin
If I fall, don't bring me back.
Posts: 410
|
Post by GreenChili on Jul 6, 2016 0:02:10 GMT
It wasn't clueless. Please don't try to make them less guilty than they are. It was trolling. A lot of it. Honestly, I don't think there was any trolling. I'm as disappointed as anyone, probably even more - but I think it was really us misinterpreting things cause we wanted it to happen SOOOOOO bad. I do blame them for not bringing LSH cause I think it was a bad decision, I do - but I don't think they trolled us. It just wasn't as important to them as it was to us...
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 6, 2016 6:34:18 GMT
It wasn't clueless. Please don't try to make them less guilty than they are. It was trolling. A lot of it. Honestly, I don't think there was any trolling. I'm as disappointed as anyone, probably even more - but I think it was really us misinterpreting things cause we wanted it to happen SOOOOOO bad. I do blame them for not bringing LSH cause I think it was a bad decision, I do - but I don't think they trolled us. It just wasn't as important to them as it was to us... I think they were trolling. Finally including elements of her story, refusing to say she is cut out of the show for years and having all others return, while she is name dropped more than the guys who did returned combined?
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 6, 2016 10:30:53 GMT
Honestly, I don't think there was any trolling. I'm as disappointed as anyone, probably even more - but I think it was really us misinterpreting things cause we wanted it to happen SOOOOOO bad. I do blame them for not bringing LSH cause I think it was a bad decision, I do - but I don't think they trolled us. It just wasn't as important to them as it was to us... I think they were trolling. Finally including elements of her story, refusing to say she is cut out of the show for years and having all others return, while she is name dropped more than the guys who did returned combined? Same here. The worst was avoiding to answer any question about her + that truths and lies game (which I don't know what to think about), while at the same time putting hints everywhere. Honeslty, if they had said she was cut out, or there hadn't been that game, I'd say OK, she could appear (according to the hints) but she won't; they are just respecting/remembering the character of Catelyn without her alter ego (which is hard) for the RV's plot; and I wouldn't complain despite of the fact I see the hints But if she is cut, then please, say it. If y ou avoid her questions and then put those hints, for me it's trolling. And if you had avoided the questions, but wouldn't have put the hints, then I'd be OK too, it wouldn't be trolling. But all these things combined? It was NOT NECESSARY, unless you want to laugh at some readers. -........................................................................................ As I said, the hints alone are not necessarily indicative of anything BUT with the questions and the game, which resulted to be a fake one), they are And the hints were huge, almost at the same level as the Valyrian fire. There were hints of wildfire in Bran's visions, the conversation with Olenna, in ep9 when Dany is taking to Tyrion..... LSH hints were also in Bran's visions, name dropped with Edmure the Blackfish and Walder Frey, and talking about how she was killed, after several seasons almost not mentioning her and now, she is mentioned several times in fewer episodes. Plus, there was the Brotherhooh, who had turned evil; and Jaime /The Hound as speculation One can say that the hints were for Arya to kill Walder.but then I'd like to know why is Catelyn and not Robb mentioned there several times. Furthermore, there is the theme of the season (arise and revenge) and the fact that several people return in deadlyalive conditions: Jon, The Mountain, Benjen and Beric. (even the Hound) The hints were huge, and real. They alone, could mean nothing, but everything combined, they are. The same for Wildfire, it was really well settled. But it could not have happened and I'd say the hints were huge too.
|
|
|
Post by stoneheartsrevenge on Jul 6, 2016 14:15:28 GMT
Honestly, I don't think there was any trolling. I'm as disappointed as anyone, probably even more - but I think it was really us misinterpreting things cause we wanted it to happen SOOOOOO bad. I do blame them for not bringing LSH cause I think it was a bad decision, I do - but I don't think they trolled us. It just wasn't as important to them as it was to us... I think they were trolling. Finally including elements of her story, refusing to say she is cut out of the show for years and having all others return, while she is name dropped more than the guys who did returned combined? Yeah I agree with this. They underused Catelyn when she was on the show, then almost forgot about her and then suddenly this season we were bombarded with references and name drops etc. Hell, they didn't even her name when it was warranted in season 4 (your sister ) and yet we got it several times this season. And then wasn't there that Lem actor trolling us all too? All very annoying I must say
|
|
kelly
Fleabottom Peasant
Posts: 16
|
Post by kelly on Jul 23, 2016 8:35:58 GMT
I heard Comicon is happening, did anyone ask the LSH question to the panel?
|
|
|
Post by boojam on Jul 23, 2016 9:39:45 GMT
I heard Comicon is happening, did anyone ask the LSH question to the panel? Seems they no longer take questions from the floor any more , or at least they are submitted before hand and filtered. With that many panelists , in one hour, there is no time to really ask.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 23, 2016 11:19:59 GMT
I heard Comicon is happening, did anyone ask the LSH question to the panel? Seems they no longer take questions from the floor any more , or at least they are submitted before hand and filtered. With that many panelists , in one hour, there is no time to really ask. And they probably are afraid
|
|
kelly
Fleabottom Peasant
Posts: 16
|
Post by kelly on Jul 23, 2016 20:01:59 GMT
Guess we are not getting the answers from there then. Too bad...
|
|
|
Post by kingeomer on Jul 24, 2016 11:38:45 GMT
Probably not.
I'm nerd enough that I like to read why folks who adapt written works choose to include certain things and omit others. Maybe when the show's run is done, D&D will discuss some reasons why they omitted certain plot lines.
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 27, 2016 12:46:17 GMT
|
|
|
Post by kingeomer on Oct 17, 2016 13:09:29 GMT
I hate to dredge up an old thread but Richard Madden did an interview with Hollywood Reporter that was posted today and was asked about Lord Stoneheart rumors. Have you seen the fan theories that Lord Stoneheart is going to make an appearance on Game of Thrones as a vengeful Robb Stark back from the dead as a zombie?
That would be my mother…. But the theory is that it would be you, Lord Stoneheart, instead of your mother, Lady Stoneheart, who returns in the books.I’ve not heard anything, of course. I suppose I wouldn’t have the phone call, because they’re very secretive about everything, unless you get some of the cast drunk and they’ll tell you what they are doing.... I like the answer that he says..."that would be my mother."
|
|
|
Post by MarcusAntonius on Mar 12, 2017 22:31:12 GMT
Loll
|
|
|
Post by kingeomer on Mar 13, 2017 12:45:49 GMT
Well, they had a really big opportunity to bring her back and chose not to take it.
|
|
|
Post by stoneheartsrevenge on Mar 13, 2017 14:49:48 GMT
|
|
|
Post by TheMadQueen on Mar 13, 2017 14:51:43 GMT
D&D are shady af. We see you. We remember.
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Mar 15, 2017 19:01:46 GMT
no no no!!! These words really hurt! why??!!!
|
|
|
Post by Damorian on Apr 12, 2017 8:37:49 GMT
For the record, full SXSW panel is now on youtube: The question "If you could bring one person back, who would it be?" is posed to them by Sophie at around the 20:05 mark. Then @ 20:50-20:58, after some Hodor banter, David says to her: "I miss your mom, Michelle Fairley is one of the great actresses..." (*cue riotous applause*) In fairness and its proper context, I don’t think they were trolling anyone, but it’s still a bit ironic or frustrating of them to say that while playing dumb to the subtext that they had the opportunity to bring her back and passed. Any conversations in the ballpark of the character, they just continue point blank to pretend she doesn’t exist, which I still find kinda weird now she’s irrevocably been cut.
|
|