|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 3, 2016 0:50:32 GMT
Rant alert! The finale was even worse than I expected it to be, wanted to throw something at the screen. D&D just don't have the guts and the creativity to bring LSH in. They already have trouble with the existing characters. A part of me wants to riot and start a petition or something, to let them give us what we want . But then I realize this might be for the best, just imagine how they would f*** her character up anyway. We would be excited to see her, and a few scenes later we would regret it because they would find countless of ways to ruin it. So you guys still hoping for season 7 LSH? Technically there is still a way to write her in, but with Filthy Frey gone... It really was not satisfying at all to see his death. Not because of LSH not doing it, but it felt rushed... "Oh, almost forgot about the Frey guys, let's do this quickly" Characters spontaneously dropping dead left and right every time a new scene starts... I would totally make another video on how LSH should have done the RW 2.0, but it all feels kinda silly now. And thank you for the cake. I know it's going to sound as if I don't like LSH, although it's the contrary. But I don't like when people fool readers like if they were monkeys SO: I would have preferred to see her (and even to see her "destroyed" by the script - or killed in the next episode) than not seeing her after: -massive hints all the season(trolling) -showrunners not wanting to answer questions about LSH -2 truths and one lie game -Jaime having secret conversations -Jaime in the woods -Cersei's foreshadowing was certain-, why not Cat's= -Benjen and Gregor are alive: Jon is alive: is a season with a theme about that topic. -you have an incredible cliffhanger with Brienne -Jaime and Brienne with LSH -BWB in the Riverlands.......
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 3, 2016 13:25:03 GMT
Rant alert! The finale was even worse than I expected it to be, wanted to throw something at the screen. D&D just don't have the guts and the creativity to bring LSH in. They already have trouble with the existing characters. A part of me wants to riot and start a petition or something, to let them give us what we want . But then I realize this might be for the best, just imagine how they would f*** her character up anyway. We would be excited to see her, and a few scenes later we would regret it because they would find countless of ways to ruin it. So you guys still hoping for season 7 LSH? Technically there is still a way to write her in, but with Filthy Frey gone... It really was not satisfying at all to see his death. Not because of LSH not doing it, but it felt rushed... "Oh, almost forgot about the Frey guys, let's do this quickly" Characters spontaneously dropping dead left and right every time a new scene starts... I would totally make another video on how LSH should have done the RW 2.0, but it all feels kinda silly now. And thank you for the cake. I know it's going to sound as if I don't like LSH, although it's the contrary. But I don't like when people fool readers like if they were monkeys SO: I would have preferred to see her (and even to see her "destroyed" by the script - or killed in the next episode) than not seeing her after: -massive hints all the season(trolling) -showrunners not wanting to answer questions about LSH -2 truths and one lie game -Jaime having secret conversations -Jaime in the woods -Cersei's foreshadowing was certain-, why not Cat's= -Benjen and Gregor are alive: Jon is alive: is a season with a theme about that topic. -you have an incredible cliffhanger with Brienne -Jaime and Brienne with LSH -BWB in the Riverlands....... Delusional Turner stans are claiming oh "she thought Frey's sons were also on the list". Riiiighhtttt. Really all of this and having Benjen in total 2 episodes and 3 scenes...it's just massively disappointing. But it's them depriving the show of a great plot twist and satisfying way of getting rid of the Freys. It's their own loss.
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 3, 2016 14:27:11 GMT
I know it's going to sound as if I don't like LSH, although it's the contrary. But I don't like when people fool readers like if they were monkeys SO: I would have preferred to see her (and even to see her "destroyed" by the script - or killed in the next episode) than not seeing her after: -massive hints all the season(trolling) -showrunners not wanting to answer questions about LSH -2 truths and one lie game -Jaime having secret conversations -Jaime in the woods -Cersei's foreshadowing was certain-, why not Cat's= -Benjen and Gregor are alive: Jon is alive: is a season with a theme about that topic. -you have an incredible cliffhanger with Brienne -Jaime and Brienne with LSH -BWB in the Riverlands....... Delusional Turner stans are claiming oh "she thought Frey's sons were also on the list". Riiiighhtttt. Really all of this and having Benjen in total 2 episodes and 3 scenes...it's just massively disappointing. But it's them depriving the show of a great plot twist and satisfying way of getting rid of the Freys. It's their own loss. Did she really say that? No.....that's too much for me. Yes, it's their loss. And I can't understand it. Shame for them Anyway, virtual cakes and ales for all of you. I had a great time in this thread. Maybe it will last longer, if some "pearls" like this one appear again. If not, we wiill see eachother in other threads If any of you go to the comic con and have the opportunity to ask showrunners what happened with her, you will be my heroes.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 3, 2016 14:35:31 GMT
Delusional Turner stans are claiming oh "she thought Frey's sons were also on the list". Riiiighhtttt. Really all of this and having Benjen in total 2 episodes and 3 scenes...it's just massively disappointing. But it's them depriving the show of a great plot twist and satisfying way of getting rid of the Freys. It's their own loss. Did she really say that? No.....that's too much for me. Yes, it's their loss. And I can't understand it. Shame for them Anyway, virtual cakes and ales for all of you. I had a great time in this thread. Maybe it will last longer, if some "pearls" like this one appear again. If not, we wiill see eachother in other threads If any of you go to the comic con and have the opportunity to ask showrunners what happened with her, you will be my heroes. Turner didn't care enough to clarify but her fans are always ready with excuse for whatever stupid thing she says. There are threads about 'Did Turner just lie?" on reddit and imdb and there are plenty of people jumping to her defence I bet someone on Con will ask. At least I hope so but do we really want to hear their answer? 9 out of 10 chance it will be something insulting to Catelyn or her fans
|
|
Steve Stark
Grumpkin
Trying to edit my book and get it published by December. Got my cover art done a few months ago! :)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Steve Stark on Jul 3, 2016 15:39:32 GMT
All I know is I've been eating QUITE a bit of fiber, and I'm just about to head back to the States to pay a few folks a special visit.
**Looks for the really nice house with a really nice porch**
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 3, 2016 16:33:17 GMT
All I know is I've been eating QUITE a bit of fiber, and I'm just about to head back to the States to pay a few folks a special visit. **Looks for the really nice house with a really nice porch**
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 3, 2016 16:44:18 GMT
I don't know if she did that on purpose. I don't know if I want to know it, either. It has been extremely disappointing.
Of course if someone asks her at ComicCon I'll like to hear the answer.
And I'd love to hear someone asking the showrunners why did they put so many hints, why did they mix that track (like sati commented) or if they have decided to finally answer us: So it's LSH over? Yes or not.
I think we deserve that.
|
|
Steve Stark
Grumpkin
Trying to edit my book and get it published by December. Got my cover art done a few months ago! :)
Posts: 262
|
Post by Steve Stark on Jul 3, 2016 16:47:21 GMT
I don't know if she did that on purpose. I don't know if I want to know it, either. It has been extremely disappointing. Of course if someone asks her at ComicCon I'll like to hear the answer. And I'd love to hear someone asking the showrunners why did they put so many hints, why did they mix that track (like sati commented) or if they have decided to finally answer us: So it's LSH over? Yes or not. I think we deserve that.
Agreed.
Although I think they deserve a punch to the groin, regardless of what they say/make up.
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 3, 2016 17:03:02 GMT
I don't know if she did that on purpose. I don't know if I want to know it, either. It has been extremely disappointing. Of course if someone asks her at ComicCon I'll like to hear the answer. And I'd love to hear someone asking the showrunners why did they put so many hints, why did they mix that track (like sati commented) or if they have decided to finally answer us: So it's LSH over? Yes or not. I think we deserve that.
Agreed.
Although I think they deserve a punch to the groin, regardless of what they say/make up.
The trolling has been huge.....
|
|
|
Post by day dreamer on Jul 3, 2016 17:58:27 GMT
D&D think so little of Catelyn they probably didn't even realize they were trolling, even though there was massive amounts of it this year.
|
|
kelly
Fleabottom Peasant
Posts: 16
|
Post by kelly on Jul 3, 2016 21:48:03 GMT
Yes, we need clear answers, this torture has been going on long enough.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 4, 2016 6:01:13 GMT
D&D think so little of Catelyn they probably didn't even realize they were trolling, even though there was massive amounts of it this year. It's possible. They may think it's nothing just like TWD showrunners think that cliffhanger was inspired But given that someone actually asked about LSH last year and they shushed him they may be less clueless than they appear
|
|
|
Post by Paid Debt Lannister on Jul 5, 2016 1:49:56 GMT
It wasn't clueless. Please don't try to make them less guilty than they are. It was trolling. A lot of it.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 5, 2016 6:02:55 GMT
It wasn't clueless. Please don't try to make them less guilty than they are. It was trolling. A lot of it. I think they were just cynically trying to keep people watching, by not saying anything they still left a room for her to show up. Lots of people love Cleganebowl and some said Tommen killed the hype. Please. Sandor and Gregor are both in the show, so that's most likely happening. What I am wondering is if they will actually try to top themselves and shamelessly tease Stoneheart in season 7 But no one will fall for that now.
|
|
kelly
Fleabottom Peasant
Posts: 16
|
Post by kelly on Jul 5, 2016 8:40:28 GMT
So, should I start a petition? Would there be backers, or should I let it go?
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 5, 2016 8:51:30 GMT
So, should I start a petition? Would there be backers, or should I let it go? I think the only shot is if anyone attending Comic Con asks them, but really I don't think there is anything they can possibly say that would convince me - and I think others - that not including LSH was a good idea and they were completely innocent in all their trolling. I think one of the ugliest things that came out of it is that they seem determined to spread the ultra violent/cold and unfeeling Stark thing both to Sansa and Arya and with both of them they overdid it - I didn't find Walder's death satisfying. It came with a huge price - of the gigantic chalk of Arya's innocence that in a well written show she would never get back. If it was LSH it would be totally different.
|
|
|
Post by kingeomer on Jul 5, 2016 12:49:10 GMT
meeraoftarth, I am hoping someone will ask the question at Comic Con this year. I believe Benioff and Weiss are going this year. And they shouldn't prohibit the question like they did at the Comic Con after season 4.
|
|
|
Post by Admin on Jul 5, 2016 18:28:41 GMT
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 5, 2016 19:40:14 GMT
|
|
|
Post by meeraoftarth on Jul 5, 2016 20:22:00 GMT
The hype for season7 is here guys I have to say that I had a similar thought concerning that the BWB might have been broken in two (Anguy didn't appear with Thoros)...I think I mentioned that. But I think it's highly unlikely they will bring LSH now that there are only two seasons left, and almost certainly will be shortened. Who knows? Maybe the BWB has another important theme in the books that has yet to appear, and that's the reason they brought them back. As much as I would like LSH to happen, it won't happen unless they fall short of ideas for next seasons and they decided to use her plot at S7 because of that, which of course, is still possible concerning the BWB is tehre, but I don't think so. It will be interesting if someones asks them if she is definitely cut out; but the better question would be why are the reasons you cut her out? If they answer this, then there's no LSH. If they keep avoiding the question....well, there will always be someone with hype And certainly I am not one, but you will infect me with your enthusiasm and maybe I'll be on the hype train again!!!
|
|